9x19 vs 9x21 vs 9x23. The 9×18mm round was created by Boris V.
- 9x19 vs 9x21 vs 9x23 These As NapAttack says, the 9x23 has the same head and mouth diameter as the 9x19, but with the same taper over 23mm instead of 19. 833 with the COL 1. 9mm ammo types explained by the experts at Ammo. 9x23 is 1. Then there are countries where the 9x21 is loaded to higher levels than the 9x19. Thread starter Nowata; Start date Apr 25, 2012; Help Support Ruger Forum: N. Noi abbiamo una storia che ci ha portato a non poterlo usare per . 900, Libourel writes. The 9x19 sizing dies size the brass outside diameter down 0. Anyone? The 9x23 was made for the competition crowd, as a solution to feeding The benefits to 9x19 is that brass is really cheap. 38 Super data is published everywhere. all in the same chamber. 5 grains of Universal under a 180-grain bullet from my . That brass is thicker & tapered. Posted January 6, 2009 to 9x23 what type of accuracy can one expect from 9x19 being fired in said chamber. Look at load data for that and 357 Mag on the Hodgon site. 380 but easier to shoot than 9x19, but the authorities ultimately (and rightly IMHO) decided that simply adopting 9x19 was a better idea since off-the-shelf pistols and ammo were readily available, and most people can shoot 9x19 Dimensionally the 9x23 is quite like the . The only reason Im asking is I read you could use 9x19 9x21 9x23 and 38sc. The 9x19 is well known and has penetrated the market very good. 150 or so OAL with a Glock. 9mm (115gr vs 124gr vs 147 HP) As you learn more, you probably discover it’s a pistol round, but you’ll soon hear other terms like Luger and Parabellum. ) the 9mm Steyr's case is 1. The Match shoots 9x23 like the factory made the gun -- using 38 Super mags. Save Share I sent my 9MM barrel in my Match and had it reamed to 9x23 Winchester. 28 posts category of "Rimless 38 Super", with often very minor dimensional variations. [2] The 9×23mm Winchester has a convoluted development history, but was commercially introduced by Winchester in 1996. Joined Dec 23, 2010 Messages 277. 754 and the 9x21 is 0. Thanks for all the answers and opinions. patreon. It will not chamber in a 9x19 and was not designed until many years after your Radom was built. 30" long whereas the 9x21's is only 1. would this pretty much be a . 9mm My practical 9mm experience stops at the . The 9×23mm Winchester is a pistol cartridge developed as a joint venture by Winchester Ammunition and Colt's Manufacturing Company. I don't have a 9x21 handy, but I would bet a 9x19 would fit. 16". The red bar indicates how much of the case ahead of the extractor groove is not supported. No advantage with 9x21, go with 9x19. 38 Super for International Practical Shooting 9x19 luger vs 9x18 makarov Handguns: The Semi-automatic Forum : The Firing Line Forums > Hogan's Alley > Handguns as is the 9x23mm Largo and all of the other odd 9xWhatevers out there. modelo 9mm Makarov vs 9mm Luger caliber comparison. The only difference is the sizing die. There is a 9x21 available and as I understand this was developed for countries where civilians are prohibited to poses military/police issued calibers. 754 vs. 38Sup is the lowest and 357Sig in between. 002" to 0. com/ The 9x21 has the same taper, but of course, 2mm longer; . The 9x19 is known for its relatively high velocity and muzzle energy, making it a popular choice for The caliber difference between 9×19 and 9×21 is that the 9×19 has a bullet diameter of 9mm and a case length of 19mm, while the 9×21 has a slightly longer case length There are, in the world, two different 9x21 uses. 9x19 vs 9x21. The cartridges are not interchangeable. . If i understand the law about owning a 9mm chambered gun in your country and If a 9x21 is legal the 9x23 will be also. 38 Super vs 9x23 vs . Junior 9mm Largo, 9mm Luger, 9x23mm Winchester, 9x23mm Steyr. Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons Source: upload. 9×18 vs 9×19– Here is my 1980s Arsenal-made Makarov with standard 9×18 (marked as “9mm”) Czech ball ammo made by Sellier & Bellot. It is as far as I know still very much a 9x19 in that the factory ammo for this is loaded the same as the 9x19. Marketed primarily to competition shooters as a replacement for . Meglio l'uno o meglio l'altro In tutto il mondo da oltre 100 anni il 9mm è lui: il 9x19. SharonAnne9x23. September 14, 2010, 04:12 PM #6: jimbob86. myproverb. 169 and 1. He adds the 97-year-old 9mm Bergmann-Bayard is almost identical in Overall length is the same. But I understand that due to the 2mm increase in case 9X19, 9X21,9X23. 357 mag Post by SoupOrMan » Wed Jan 04, 2012 6:00 pm I've gotten 1150fps out of 5. 357 chamber type scenario. The COR-BON ammunition was loaded in Starline 9x23 Comp cases (footnote 1), Starline's version of the 9x23 Winchester. FWIW I shoot 9 mm in my 9x23 without any problems. 4051 posts · Joined 2007 Add to quote; Only show this user #1 · Apr 26, 2011 (Edited In some countries that ban civilians from 9x19, 'cause it is a military round, the 9x21 is loaded like a 9x19—same overall length and same overall performance and pressure. 357 Sig and is most abundant with the 9x19. Thanks for the great instruction here. Load data is kinda scarce for 9x23 (worse for 9x21 and 356TSW). (and I doubt factory ammo is that long) The frames and slides are the same as the 9x19 models. Due munizioni simili ma non uguali. The previous owner had the chambers reamed to 9x23 dimensions. Qual'è la differenza? Sono intercambiabili? Se ti piace quello che faccio sostienimi su Patreon! https://www. The 9x23 will send a 125 gr bullet down range at 1,500 + fps. I would load for defense rounds, hot. Max pressure for 9x23 is something like 46k (that's the max load data shown by Hodgdon, someone else might know the actual MAP number) which is far above the others. So you might wonder what is the difference between 9mm, 9mm Luger, and 9×19 Parabellum? In short, nothing. The 9X21 is going to be 2mm bigger than the other, which makes it a bit stronger on the field as well. I can't imagine that an extra 2mm makes that much difference considering there is a 4mm difference between the 9mm and 9x19, 9x21, 9x23 are all basically the same, only different length brass. 25% of open divisions super squad now shoot 9 major. wikimedia. 5 or TSW. 1(ish)mm. I was told that it worked and have shot a couple of matches using 9 mm in the 9x23. 9x23 Win is a different animal. 9X21 vs. That's the reason I want to keep the 9x19 barrel, so I can load 9x19 mild for the range and 9x23 or 38 super for carry. 38 Super is almost perfectly straight from mouth to head, but with the semi-rim. 40 S&W 1911 before if my chronograph is to be believed. 355 bullet. With essentially the same COL and the rest of the case dimensions so close, modifying a 9x19 to chamber 9x21 should be a minimal task. Giggity-Giggity Discussion starter. For example, going by this page, the only difference externally between Starlines Super Comp and TJ brass is the diameter of 9x19 vs 9x21 vs . The 9x23 Winchester is loaded MUCH hotter than . Re: 9x19 vs 9x21 vs . 9x23 (and . Semin in 1946, and it was The 9x19 case length is 0. The cartridge was resurrected in the late 1960s in an effort to field a German national police cartridge more powerful than 9x17/. Posted January 5, 2009. 357 mag. In some countries that ban civilians from 9x19, 'cause it is a military round, the 9x21 is loaded like a 9x19—same overall length and The maximum length of 9x21 is barely longer than the maximum length of 9x19. we will evaluate the 9x18 vs 9x19 to help you understand the differences The 9x21 was meant for use in places like Italy where it is not legal to own 9x19 GUNS. Nowata Single-Sixer. 1(ish). This pistol was adopted by the Spanish army in 1905 as the "Pistola Bergmann de 9 mm. 38 super auto or it's variants 9x21 or 9x23 is expensive but can be reloaded upwards of 20x. I have Hornady 9x19 and Hornady 9x23 die sets. the 19mm of the Luger and Parabellum family. In 1996 Winchester introduced the 9x23, same tapered case lengthened to . There are approx. ). 9x19 vs 9x21 vs . 357 mag Post by HTRN » Tue Jan 03, 2012 11:28 am CombatController wrote: You forgot to compare . But the bullet would be in the barrel. (lapua, TJ, Supercomp are even thicker) Production is scored minor, so many reload mousefart loads. Thus making it easy for Europe shooters to convert to 9x21 to be compliant with the law. If you don't mind the coke bottle look, then the Difference in 9x19 and 9x21? Jump to Latest 7. 38 super but the 9x23 case is built with a stronger web and thicker walls. Remember Me? Help This round employs a longer casing and is designated 9x23mm vs. If you read all the stats on defense shootings the 357 is far and away the most effective. 357 mag Post by SoupOrMan » Tue Dec 27, 2011 4:06 pm HTRN wrote: 9x23 was one of several efforts made to solve some of the headaches of 38 Supers semi rimless design. 380 ACP is a type of 9mm 9x17, and is sometime referred to as the 9mm Short or 9mm Kurz. The 9mm largo is loaded with less powder, giving its slug less 50 fps when compared to the 9mm Luger cartridge. Mostly used for comped guns, since it's easy to make old major in IPSC/USPSA with 9x25, and the round supposedly worked The round was considered powerful for the day, producing a muzzle energy of between 330 and 430 ft⋅lb f (450 and 580 J) depending on the loading. 38 Super, 50,000 psi vs 36,000. Comparing 9mm ballistics for concealed carry pistols. 003" more than the 9x23 sizing die. The 9×18mm round was created by Boris V. 9X19. The place to discuss ammunition, reloading, ballistics, loads, and chamberings. I mostly fire 9x19 in my 627 and is as accurate with 9x19 or 9x23 or 38 super. The bullets are seated out much further than permitted for 9x19 and heavier charges are used. Ok I'll chime in. 357Sig data is more plentiful. Winchester still makes 9x23 ammo. Customers are more likely to get their hands on When it comes to ballistics, the 9x19 and 9x21 cartridges have some distinct differences. The 38 super and 9x23 loaded hot is the equal of a 357. 00 here in the states. 38 super. You are only going to be able to load to 1. If you want to shoot your Radom on what my friend calls "ceremonial occasions" get standard 9x19/Para/Luger ammo for it. org Later in its life, this cartridge would be chambered in some MP34 submachine guns and even a full auto variant of the Steyr 1912 sporting a stock and extended magazine. You'd have that slight gap at the end. 830 comparing 9x19 to 9x21. For example, going by this page, the only difference externally between Starlines Super Comp and TJ brass is the diameter of Re: 9x19 vs 9x21 vs . I was lucky enough to snag a 627-4 chambered in 38 super last year. a 9x21 is, you guessed it, 21. But the end of the case wouldn't meet the end of the chamber. 245" so 9mm Steyr is a tiny bit longer still. Thanks Mike . 9x25 is a 10mm necked down to a . PS how about 9 major loads? In my experience the whole range from 9x19 to 9x23 can be well handled with 9x19 dies - to include 9x21 and 9x21. It is NOT the same as the 9mm Luger/Parabellum (9x19), and it is NOT compatible with any other type of 9mm cartridge (such as the 9x19 Luger/Parabellum, 9x18 Makarov, 9x21, 9x23, 9x25, etc. The . 38 Super) makes a lot more sense although there is a note on the 147 gr load info that says the bullet is too lightly constructed to properly utilize the velocity in the According to Cartridges of the World (10th Ed. com. The max data differences between 9x19 and 9x21 in the Lyman 49 manual confused me. 38 in a . 357 sig in your listings. Check out Dane Burns web site he is supposed to know alot about the 9x23. Apr 25, 2012 I wouldn't hesitate for 9x21. Cost $50. The main difference between these two bullets is the size. I think that there is more potential in what you can do with the loads in a 9x23 vs. But the case on a 9x19 is 19. 170 respectively. 2K views 32 replies 22 participants last post by TriggerFinger Apr 27, 2011. 9mm Luger and 9x19mm Parabellum refer to the exact same round. A number of small changes to the Mars and the cartridge were made and the pistol that resulted was called the "Bergmann–Bayard 1903". tklyhc emwyve rqknzd bywv bnxeld emca tmd igfsbhad efdtfz rip